Excellent drop rate ^^

lvl 31 UD rogue. did this by taking them 1 by 1. when the guards do their little cast when they dont attack, just back off to the distance where u can either Throw or Fire a ranged weapon.
this will take u out of the range to be hit each time you hit them

can be done. just be careful

not that bad to do.......
drop rates are LOW.

Watch for LV40 character just a bit north of the small camp.

Cords for this quest are, 28/84 on the Alterac Mountains.

P.S.
wtf is that fire shield thing supposed to do anyways?

You need to be at the interment camp that's where the drop rate is highest. Coords are 19,87.

  As a Warlock this quest is easy to solo at lvl 32 as long as you stay away from the house just outside the camp.

in addition take two freaking minutes to see who will be isolated at all and if they are when and where.

I soled this as a level 30 mage.  You can hang around outside and just pick off the solo ones.  Attacking two of them was a struggle, but possible.  Takes a while to do it at this level though.

There are at least five who just patrol by themselves, for me it was easier wait for them than to take out the pairs who seem impossible to separate.
  As suggested above, the (nonobvious to me) trick  was realizing that when their red shield goes up they WILL NOT MOVE so just back up and laugh at them, thow/cast, until the shield goes away.  I died several times before working this out, and it's a looong jog back from the graveyard.

I'm a lvl 30 Mage, didn't have problems with the guards or mages. You might get an add off of the two gate gaurds but you can pick the rest off one by one...no problem with the tokens, got them all pretty fast.  Last guy sucks with the lvl 36 Warden in the same room. Sheeped her and killed the undead.

Two of us did this one last night, level 31 warlock and priest. We just took the road north from Tarren, looking for yeti in the Hercular's Rod quest. Had to kill a couple level 34 ogres to get to the yeti, and going through the yeti took us west to a field outside Dalaran.  Scouted out Dalaran and the internment camp with the eye of Kilrogg and decided to try this stone token quest.

It was a lot easier for us killing the guards than the yeti, so we cleared the perimeter and went in, cleared the yard, and found we had started to do our orange prison-breakin quest, so we kept on going. Cleared out the building, and then went into the buildings outside the fence. Had a very close battle with a level 36 mage at the very top of a building, but got the yeti quest, this quest, and the prison breakin quest done all at once, walking in one big circle.

We didn't have the red-shield/melee problem, maybe because we're casters. I used a succubus and corruption, agony, shadow bolt, wand on the guards. The succubus was useful in seducing them when we aggro'd more than 2 at a time. For casters, curse of tongues, corruption, shadow bolt, and just drained their mana while the succubus attacked them. We usually didn't draw more than 2 attackers, and mostly worked on one mob at a time.

The drop rate must just be variable. My partner had 10 stones before I had 5, but as we fought our way back out, I picked the other 5 up quickly. Of the 2 quests we were doing at once in there, the drop rate on this one was more of a problem than the difficulty of the "prison break-in" quest, so just had to be patient.

Didnt really like the quest, with lowbi gear as 30 lvl rogue. Heavy Silk Bandages and gouge were my rescue.

Droprate was bout 25%, like said before.

These guys are not worth it for rogues.  I know a couple of people said it already, but I just created an account as well to agree with them.  On top of everything said already, on two occasions with me, they brought up the shield while stunned. 

Go to hillsbrad fields and go north. as you walk north youll see it to the nw

I'm a dagger rogue on a pve server so Alliance is no problem. I was able to easily handle this at level 31... even as a melee class.

Your best friends here are going to be crippling poison and a whole lotta bandages. I have 225 first aid so I can buy and use heavy runecloth bandages meaning I only need about 5 seconds to fill my life back up to full.

Try to clear the solo patrols around the linked pairs first. Then stealth and sap one of the paired stone guards once you've cleared the patrols. Use the time to take the other stone guard out. Their shield, once you have timing down, is no problem. It announces itself with a sound (the same sound you hear when you skill up at a trainer) before it goes up fully giving you plenty of time to back away or untarget if you pay attention and look for it. Even if it gets up fully before you can stop attacking or back away I've only ever hit the shield three times, meaning you'll take 255dmg in a worst case scenario. Once it's it's up you'll have plenty of time to bandage to full health if you need or to begin your ranged attack.

The best way to take the stone guards out fast is to open with Cheap Shot, Backstab, Gouge, Backstab, Kidney Shot, Backstab, Eviscerate. For me that formula equalled a very quick demise for the Stone Guard and usually without even allowing them to pull up their shield spell even once. I am not entirely sure but I believe that when stunned they can't get their shield off. They can proc it in the short time between stuns but if you are fast and have good timing you can keep their window of opportunity very small indeed.

I haven't noticed any corelation between percentage of health and the shield spell proc so I beleive it is a random event with a high percentage chance to proc in general, meaning they can get it off whenever as long as they are not incapacitated. Try to keep them incapacitated.

The crippling poison handles running. At 50% movement and 20% health you can take them out long before they can bring their buddies into the mix.

Conditions never stay optimal though, and chances are you will find yourself having to face two or three at a time while an annoying out of sight caster throws phantoms at you like a Congo line at a bad wedding. Don't panic. The phantoms hit for minimal damage at best. Even a crit from them is less than 40dmg. All they really do is keep you from bandaging. Focus on the guards. If you're facing multiples be ready to switch targets when you hear the sound announcing their shield going up. Take them out as fast as possible. Continue to ignore the phantoms and go take the caster out once the guards are down. If you get well and truly overwhelmed, vanish and try again.

I was able to survive a 3-on-1 and even one 4-on-1 using these guidelines.

easily soloable for rogue lvl 32.
Don't hit when the shield is on(they stop hitting as well) and try the house on the right of the camp as u face the door.They come in twos and sap saves lives and time.They even drop megeweave:D.
Co-ords are great.
Just Avoid the last florr lvl 36 mob its quite difficult...

For rogues this is just takes a bit of thinking....sneak around the camp there are two patrolling pats (usually a guard and a caster) Truely the best way to kill off a guard as a melee class is when you see the shield go up stop attacking IMMEDIATELY and attempt to get within shooting/throwing range. For the casters its quite simple use kick or pummel or shield bash etc.

im writing this while im healing up rather decent drops

When I did this quest and got to 8 stone tokens, my fellow friend, only having 3, decided to be a pussy and said "he had to go".  I tried to solo the last of the two tokens as a 31 fire mage in dalaran, thinking it was easy, but with all the elemental slaves and summoners and all the aggroeing and dying, I decided to whip up thotbott.  Ignoring all the rogue complaints, I found that I should go to the internment camp, not dalaran itself.  With that, the enemies and aggroing got easier, the drop rate got better, and every thing was finally ok instead of everything being a disastrous mess.

So under any condition, do not make my mistake, and go to the internment camp, not dalaran.

and by the way, rogues, stop complaining.  if it is too hard, don't do it.  you are the one who made the rogue.

I did this as a lvl 34 warior... And it took me like 25 to 35 min. but i got them al. :) just watch who you attack and you'll be fine.

just a wuick comment if you are doin this at the same time as getting the 4 shards from the undeads around the internment camp. the Undead are nutral untill you hit them. so for the 36 warden with the last guy on the top floor of the second building. kill her first, let your mana or energy regen then go at it to get the last shard. its unnecesary to fight both at the same time.

This drop rate is bull crap i have killed 20 of them and not one token

Good tip for this one.

The shield guys shield only protects against melee attacks so use ranged or spells to attack them when shield is up.

Rogues and Warriors will have the most trouble with these guys.

Pain in the neck quest. Coords for the camp are correct. Way too easy to pull aggro, and what's up with having to run back all the way from Tarren Mill - that bites!!!!!

P.S. Drop rate was horrible on this one

just finished. appox 45 mins, with level 32 shadow priest. drop rates around 20% off guards and got 3 from casters in between guard pulls. keep ur guard pulls clean with shadow word p, and hex on both, mind flays and finish wanding. and bring plenty of water.

Don't listen to the locs on most of these yellow posts.  The correct loc is 22, 85 ish  the concentration camp area.  Just kill all the red humans.  Very easy!

Done as a level 31 rogue. Seriously, I don't know what all you other rogues are bitching about.

Done with level 30 mage.. Pretty easy.. Didn't even have to take them one by one.. And about the drop-rate, I think it was around 20-25% here...

I found a good way to bypass the "Vengeful Shield".
As soon as the red aura comes up back off and use a range weapon. that doesn't seem to be affected by the shield.
and to fight two at once is pretty easy. as soon as one gets his shield up switch to the other attacking mob.

Really Really easy for me (31 shammy) all i did was pull 1 or 2 and killed althought shield didnt pop up that often, 1 thing you better watch out for is if you stand to close to a gap in the Fence/Hole thing fighting something else bout 2 will agro and then kill you,Also those mage/summoning dudes do drop them aswell

That shield tip helped SOOOOO much! Thanks!

-level 30 Solo Orc Warrior

Very long quest took about 2 hrs. Drop rate horrible

If you pull more than 2 doing this quest, you really need to learn to pay attention. The only mobs that are connected are the gate guards, and there are only 2 of them that are together. Ever.

Learn to pull. Watch for wandering mobs. The ones outside of the compound are easy to pick off. Grab a guard while the inner mobs are far away, pull back, and kill the 2 guards. Go back and take out the wanderers on the inside.

There is no reason to ever have to go inside the compound if you've got ranged attacks. Every mob can be lurred out. If you have to get up close and personal to a mob, do it, then run back out, and kill them where you can be safe.

And yes, that red shield hurts, but all you have to do is stop meleeing with the mob and you won't be hurt. Ranged damage and DoTs won't do blowback damage to you while the shield is up.

A tip for hunters and locks: The Follow command is a wonderful thing. If you're dealing with a mob that doesn't have long-range attacks, send in the pet, let them pick up aggro, then tell them to Follow. Once they're back to a safe spot, tell them to attack again. It'll save you from dying at the hands of unwanted pulls.

the tokens seem to drop at a 15% rate. u can do the "prison" quest while doin the token quest. (the prison quest is to kill four people for their gems) hope this helped.