Thottbot > Comments > Items > Shermanar Great-Ring
NEW! Powered by Thottbot - easily add Thottbot item tooltips to your site!
Thottbot > Comments > Items > Shermanar Great-Ring
  •   Report  Quote Reply well..
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by whoawhoa, 1.3 years ago
    its an upgrade...kinda...6 more stam, and 6 more defence than lvl 66 ring from durnhold keep ><.  what u guys think? patch and make better, or let it be another DE item?
  •   Report  Quote Reply kinda upgrade
    Score 0.37     Vote: [-] [+] by Ikhnaton, 1.3 years ago
    most upgrades be that way
    6 stam here, 6 defense there
    when all 15-17 slots have been upgraded that way... its not so kinda anymore
  •   Report  Quote Reply Dropped off aran..
    Score 0.39     Vote: [-] [+] by Loraic <Authority>, 1.3 years ago
    Dropped off aran..
    This ring is a good trade off if you already have a ton of Defense. The extra stam is nice, but don't drop below or come close to the crit/crush cap.
    Loraic
  •   Report  Quote Reply sigh
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by Americanfootballer, 1.2 years ago
    I cant believe i have a ring that is acually better/equal then this, and i havent even got past the 2nd boss yet in Karahzan. http://www.thottbot.com/i31319    The Band of Impenetrable Defences is a good ring to have, i recommend using only if you see it drop, but dont buy it from someone of course.
    •   Report  Quote Reply Except for druids this ring is better
      Score 0.40     Vote: [-] [+] by gimped_momo, 1.2 years ago
      This ring with the armor and even more so if they do upgrade it in the next patch, is superior for druids than the ring you linked.  For warrs, probably the bigger defense value is better.
  •   Report  Quote Reply Will get 195 armor i...
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by klingen, 1.2 years ago
    Will get 195 armor in patch 2.1.0
  •   Report  Quote Reply This ring is a decen...
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by D1srupta, 1.2 years ago
    This ring is a decent ring currently.

    I recently got the exalted Karazhan tanking ring and the heroic badge tanking ring.

    Upon inspection of the content patch, those rings will both blow this one out of the water. Making this still in the top few, but if you even get the lowest version of the Violet Eye ring, and the heroic ring... this ring becomes a useless drop.
  •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Shermanar Great-Ring
    Score 1.9     Vote: [-] [+] by ThePorkChopExpress, 1.1 years ago
    I heavily disagree.  This ring has armor.  This is an amazing feral druid tanking ring.
  •   Report  Quote Reply Note to Warriors:
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by Retger, 9.5 months ago
    if it has armor, stam, and def/dodge, its designed for druids. if it has stam, def, and dodge/parry/shield block, its for warriors. stop talking about how its a lackluster warrior ring.
    •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Note to Warriors:
      Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by NerfenLied, 7.2 months ago
      Paladins can't tank?
    •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Note to Warriors:
      Score 2.2     Vote: [-] [+] by superfrank, 6.9 months ago
      I don't see why warriors wouldn't want a ring with armour on it.
      •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Note to Warriors:
        Score 2.6     Vote: [-] [+] by Retger, 5.3 months ago
        Last edit: 5.3 months ago
        I don't see why warriors wouldn't want a ring with armour on it.

        Because warriors dont get 5.5 times the normal armor from items. They're better of with more stam, defense, dodge, parry, and block. You're not going to find any ring with everything.
  •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Shermanar Great-Ring
    Score 0.77     Vote: [-] [+] by Faeil Pally, 6.4 months ago
    Paladin tank here, and i want this ring, to replace Iron Band of the Unbreakable. This ring is nice. XD
  •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Shermanar Great-Ring
    Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by Angrynade, 4.8 months ago
    This ring dropped for my raid i was the off tank with my Druid my guild wouldnt let me roll and gave it too the MT a Warrior who already had better imo man i was soo pissed -.-              LF a new Guild :'(
  •   Report  Quote Reply Re: Shermanar Great-Ring
    Score 1.1     Vote: [-] [+] by Adrenath, 3.9 months ago
    This ring is a druid ring, but was still an upgrade for me as a warrior MT.  The ring I replaced with this had about 10 less stam and no armor, the only thing it had going for it was shield block value, which is of minimal importance IMO.
  • BackTop
     
    Created by Thott - Thottbot 3.51 - Feedback