Usually I like to use my ranged weapon slot for something that adds +hit, +crit and other useful aggro getting stats, which are lacking in most good tanking gear. and i like to use a thrown weapon simply because of the faster speed which can make pulling pats much easier. but in this case with the obvious tank stats i would sacrifice my +hit for some dodge, and i think that looking at the stats it should be aggreed it is a warrior weapon. yes all classes need stamina but the dodge is the clincher. a hunter or rogue who needs the dodge to stay alive should give their warrior the ranged wep with +hit and +crit 'cause something is seriously wrong. while not as good as parry dodge is extremely handy for avoiding those especially nasty hitting bosses. this is all assuming we are raiding here. in pvp this would be awesome for anyone, but do guilds usually give something this good off to a rogue for his little pvp toy?

p.s. in everything i say we are assuming that this is a tank weapon-- prob shoulda started out saying that but se la vie, not gonna rewrite post...