Ppl can argue about this all day but its this simple: hunters shudnt be allowed to roll against arms warriors or ret pallys on this, why? because they only want it for the stats and not as a main weapon, if a warrior/rogue was given an epic ranged weapon tht was awesome for hunters just because they gained 2ap the hunter wud flip out, id never roll against a hunter on a ranged weapon because at the end of the day you have raid with these ppl and screwing them over on loot thats better for them thn u is screwing yourself in the longrun