You are a prot warrior. You are not supposed to do damage, you are supposed to stand there and take one helluva beating while others around you burn down your foe. I am a 70 Arms warrior with 2h S1 axe, and I can mow through people. But unlike a prot warrior, I burn as quick as they do so I have to get the jump and DPS like mad. If you want to PvP and hold your own against other players 1 v 1 my best suggestion would be to respec. Tanks are great....if you have a party behind you.

DonTuka 70 MS Warrior/Skywall/Reckoning