1. Anyone can lie about what class they play/like the most

2. "It's an upgrade" isn't the only thing you should be considering. If I had to choose between a hunter who attends all raids and an MS warr/ret pally who can only make one or two days it should go to the hunter (or they should at least be allowed to roll on it). This kind of gear isn't class specific for a reason, same as Trollbane. You would hope people would be mature enough by the point they're raiding ZA to put the benefit of their guild above being an epic whore