1st cast today at skettis. was really not expecting it. unfortunetly i got the 500 health buff on 1st wish. XD. maybe next time i'll get the pet

Found ANOTHER one today. 2 pool i fished. 1st cast. Seems mr. pinchy likes me. gonna bank it hopefully get the pet in the 5 wishes i have left.

EDIT: 3rd WISH! Magical Crawdad ! YAY. Oh and i'd also like to add that after patches the cooldown for mr pinchy goes away! so do it right before patch and bam two wishes within a day of eachother.