Bears in hillsbrad are good for rank 3-4 claw, rank 1-2 is from bears in loch modan, rank 5 is from encrusted crawlers in desolace, basically for low lvl claw abil u get it from bears, then easiest to get higher lvl claw abil is from crabs, doesn't mean you need to keep the sucky pet, just get your abil from it, then ditch and teach it to a real hunters pet, a cat, wolves are good, but cats are better, specially if you get Humar, or the Rake, fast attacks,and if u get the beast mastery armor % bonus, then u have a fast pet with good tank abil.