Thottbot > Comments > Items > Maladath, Runed Blade of the Black Fli...
NEW! Wrath of the Lich King! (August 29)   NEW! Project Lore AK
  •   Report  Quote Reply better tanking weap than quel'serrar
    Score -1.2     Vote: [-] [+] by qeru, 2.2 years ago
    i don't have quel'serrar, my guild wants to buy me a compendium as i'm 3rd MT. but i think i'll tell them to save the g, since we're currently at vael and yes, this is better than quel'serrar for tanking.
    why? because +13def=.5% parry/dodge/block and it's on chance, and not to say it's pretty much useless once u hit 400 def (+100 from eq). and 300 armor? get real
    indeed quel'serrar has +12 sta, but at this point i'm quite ready to give those 120 HP (4.7k unbuffed in tanking gear anyway) up for +4 in swords, as that, even without +hit eq, will drop the miss rate signifficantly.
    may sound weird but i'm a fury tank (only have basic survival talents, last stand + toughness + shield spec), rest is fury up to full flurry, and i do crit a lot, including heroic strike, which i always use after sunders are stacked, as it's much better threat maker than sunder anyway, thus giving this sword much more potential on creating threat than quel'serrar. that's my 2c anyway

    This post is faded because it has a negative score.
    •   Report  Quote Reply Tank should be behind rogue or Fury warrior on this
      Score 1.6     Vote: [-] [+] by fanmm, 2.1 years ago
      Its a great threat weapon, but if your guild work as a team, threat shouldn't be a problem.

      "4.7k unbuffed in tanking gear anyway", you have poor gear, a tank with all tanking blue should have 4.9k unbuffed.


      * For those 10 min long boss fights Quel is much better.
    •   Report  Quote Reply *giggle*
      Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by GoldenLion, 2.0 years ago
      im not in a great guild, 1/8 Might Bloodlord's Def, and Draconian Deflector, only 2 epics there...5.2k unbuffed, 395def, 7600 ac    :)
      •   Report  Quote Reply hm...
        Score -1.6     Vote: [-] [+] by bacontree01, 2.0 years ago
        Last edit: 2.0 years ago
        6500, 9k AC, 430ish Def. GG

        This post is faded because it has a negative score.
        •   Report  Quote Reply Wow you are so cool bacontree
          Score -2.2     Vote: [-] [+] by Stardrinker, 2.0 years ago
          Last edit: 2.0 years ago
          12k AC, 9400HP, 430 Def. gg nub I am so much cooler and better than you. My stats as stated here proves it without a doubt.....or any evidence beyond my keyboard warrior skills.

          This post is faded because it has a negative score.
          •   Report  Quote Reply Zomg?
            Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by jugwalker, 2.0 years ago
            1200000000 AC, 10000000000000000000 Hp (unbuffed, nubs), 5050505050505050 DEF, in my DPS gear, btw. get the fuck oevr it, so you have better ststas, better gear, and the guys a noob. chances are, he'll never read this page again
    •   Report  Quote Reply 4700 unbuffed is very low
      Score 0.34     Vote: [-] [+] by Corners, 2.0 years ago
      No offense but my rogue almost has that much hp. My warrior has well over 5400 in tank gear. You might wana stick to just being a furry warrior
    •   Report  Quote Reply 4.7k?
      Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by Agentsmith1818, 1.9 years ago
      4,700 health for a 3rd MT? You might want to work on your stamina a little bit first before you start worrying about a Maladath for tanking. My paladin has 6,200 unbuffed in healing gear, with 7.4k armor. Not in Naxx, basically all BWL gear. 4.7k health is not going to get you very far as a tank. That's just my 2c. :)
  • BackTop
     
    Created by Thott - Thottbot 3.71 - Feedback