Thottbot > Comments > Items > Bonescraper > rogues go find someth...
  NEW! Project Lore - Soloing - Dorkins Does Dailies Episode 25 - The Wyrmrest Accord - Part 3
  •   Report  Quote Reply Upgrade from Julie's Dagger
    Score 0.53     Vote: [-] [+] by Stoke69, 3.3 years ago
    1st Baron run and it dropped for me.  Upgraded from Julie's Dagger so I am happy.
    •   Report  Quote Reply Eh for rogues
      Score 0.00     Vote: [-] [+] by Kaylen, 3.3 years ago
      Now, I am not saying 'Boo for hunters or rouges or wars..'...or whoever choses to roll on this, but correct me if I am wrong but dont rogues usually want a slow mainhand (not really slow but a high top end dmg) so they deal more with their abilities?

      Personally I play a hunter as a main and when I started playing my rogue I noticed a nice dmg increase whenever I used the wep with the higher top end dmg in main hand.

      Again, I do not claim to be an expert at playing a rogue, but I do have a fury warrior also so I am not a complete melee newb ^_~.

      So I have to conclude that this wep wouldnt be better for a hunter, or a war, or a rogue, but probably about as good for any of the classes that could use it
      1)For the melee aspect
      2)For the +30 atp

      One more thing To add, you cant say it isnt that great for a hunter because 'They can get Bone Slicing Hatchets' Yes there are better weps out there but you can say that about all the classes in debate on this item.
      •   Report  Quote Reply ERRRR........WRONG
        Score 0.53     Vote: [-] [+] by Stingray580, 3.2 years ago
        One we want a fast off hand wep for poisons
        Two finishing moves (at least some of them) scale with attack power
      •   Report  Quote Reply This is a rogue's off-hand dagger
        Score 1.5     Vote: [-] [+] by taliafears, 3.1 years ago
        This is a rogue's off-hand dagger, probably the best blue one in the game.

        Rogues want fast attack speed on off hand for poisons.  As of 1.12, the only blue I know of that is faster than this is julie's, which has lower dps.

        On an off-hand dagger, all procs occur half as often, so static bonuses are basically always better.

        Attack Power is the best stat for a rogue, if you work out the math AP is the single largest contributor to a rogue's damage.  Only +20 agility could compete with this, which does not occur on any blue dagger.

        AP is easier for other classes to acquire.  Warriors get 2 AP per strength.  Hunters get 2 ranged AP per agility.  It is certainly a nice dagger for both of them though, and could easily be an upgrade.

        However, it IS best for a dagger rogue, and also it is THE best off-hand that a rogue could acquire before they go epic (and better than many epics).  I am pretty easy going and wouldn't be offended if a warr or hunter rolled against me for this, but I do show restraint on items that are better for them, and I appreciate when it's reciprocated.
  • BackTop
     
    Created by Thott - Feedback - Thottbot 3.71 /